Follow Us on Twitter for All Your Testosterone Filled Updates > www.twitter.com/planetZman
By Robin Robinson
Contributing writer and whisky ambassador, Robin Robinson takes us an Part 3 of our journey into the magical land of Scotland and it’s most powerful golden nectar.
OK kids, class is back in session. Summer’s here and it’s hot, so try to pay attention. Now, if you’ve been following your lessons from Parts I and II, you now know a little about how whisky is made, what its made from, where it comes from and why you should be drinking it.
For you remedial types, go back and review the first lessons before going on. For our prodigies, apple-polishers and general newbie whisky geeks, you have now been doing extra-curricular work in tasting, mooching and even a little research on your own. We’re now moving into the big time: buying, appreciating, stocking and entertaining with Scotch whiskies. Next stop after this: kilts, haggis, bagpipe bands and referring to people as “lads and lasses”… But first, the basics.
You’ll want to create an initial stock of brands and types of whiskies that reflect the entire range of what Scotland has to offer. Upon completion of this lesson, you’ll impress the hell out of your friends who thought all you had to offer was beer, Jack Daniels and Johnnie Walker Black (not that there’s anything wrong with them, but it’s a big world out there). You’ll know what type of whisky comes from what region, what their distinctive qualities are and how they differ. This is not a matter of what is “better” than another - rather, its about developing a wider palate of tastes that reflect your new-found knowledge.
Full Disclosure alert: your humble author is the Brand Ambassador of Compass Box Whisky. They are damn fine whiskies and I’m including them in this list. You got a problem, take it up with Tommy Z.
For now, you may want to stay away from the cask strength bottlings, and look in the 40% – 46% ABV range (Alcohol By Volume: double this number to get the “proof”). This will give a good range of complexity in each of the regions without numbing your nose and tongue with the excess alcohol. Remember, we’re looking for nuance and subtlety, not a lost weekend.
Scotland has 5 distinct regions and each presents a different style of whisky:
The Highlands: the largest land mass of Scotland producing a wide variety of malts, but typically light-bodied in style, clean and crisp, known to have traces of fruit in the nose, wonderfully ethereal and elegant. Initial age ranges go from 10-15 years in the barrel before bottling. Some have of light elements of peat and smoke, others have hints of lemon and citrus. Some have a touch of all of the above. Brands to look for: Glenmorangie 10 yr.; Dalmore Cigar Malt; Compass Box Oak Cross; Oban, 14 yr; Dalwhinnie 15yr. A distinct salty entry is Old Pulteney. Enjoy them with a touch of bottled or spring water to open the nose and reveal the complex aromas.
Speyside: a separate district of the Highlands, it is to Scotland what Manhattan is to New York City: it’s where all the action is. Of the 90 or so working distilleries in Scotland, around 50 of them are in Speyside. Speyside whiskies tend to be very complex and heavy, with traces of honey, toffee and dried fruit. There’s a lot of sherry wood maturation going on here, as well as in bourbon barrels. You probably know some of the names: Macallan, Balvenie, Glenfiddich, Glenlivet. Here’s two that are special and not widely known: Glenfarclas and Tomantoul. Same rules as above: don’t be afraid of a little water to open them, and forget what John Wayne said about drinking your whisky straight as a manly act. Experiment and let the whisky reveal itself.
Lowlands: very accessible in taste, typically grassy, light and flavorful, a lot of top notes of heather and hay with a drying finish. There are only 2 remaining working distilleries in this region, (there’s really a third, Bladnoch, but its whiskies aren’t ready for wide distribution yet) the best known being Auchentoshan, one of the last distilleries in Scotland practicing the traditional Lowland style of “triple” distillation. The other is Glenkinchie. For a newbie, these may be a good way to start.
The Islands: a wide range of styles, but all will have maritime elements of varying degrees. The Orkney Islands up north produce Highland Park and Scapa. Highland Park 12 year may be one of the best under-rated whiskies made, with a light smoke and peat combined with a toffee sweetness. As we travel to the west, we come across Skye, which produces Talisker, a hardy, spicy and peaty drink. Think cold, wet winds blowing around you and this being your buffer against them. Moving down there is Isle of Mull, which produces Tobermory; Isle of Jura and Isle of Arran, each producing a whisky of the same name. All appreciated more by the experienced drinker.
Islay: Of all the islands, this one gets the most attention (its pronounced “eye-lah”). There are only 2 things God gave this island: rock and peat. From it, Islay produces some of the most distinctive and robust whiskies on the planet. The “big peats” are Laphroaig 10yr, Lagavullin 16yr, Bowmore 10yr, Ardbeg 10yr and Caol Ila 12yr (pronounced “ka-lee-la”). These produce smoky, peaty whiskies that have high phenolic content (meaning that there are a lot of medicinal and sulphury traces to the aromas). Lot’s of maritime influence, but with great subtleties of fruits and citrus, bacon smoke and chocolate. Each distillery produces a unique flavor, but newcomers may want to approach these with caution, as they are not the most accessible. Unique on the island is Bunnahabhain which produces a gentle, ethereal spirit in its 12yr and 18yr expressions, with a crisp, maritime influence and very little if any peat. The most innovative distillery in all of Scotland, however, may be Bruichladdich (pronounced “brook-lahdie”), where master distiller Jim McEwan continues to create an entire range of expressions from gentle to monsters (seemingly on a weekly basis). Speaking of monsters, don’t forget to include Compass Box’s Peat Monster in the list. John Glaser composes a beautiful balance of Caol Ila, Laphroig and Ardmore (from Speyside) to make a surprisingly accessible yet complex dram. (What a great plug, huh?)
Last is the Kintyre peninsula district of Cambelltown, down at the foot of it that once contained more distilleries than you can shake a shiel at. Now there are only 3: Springbank, (which also produces Longrow and Hazelton), Glengyle and Glen Scotia. You definitely want to pick up a Springbank 10yr first, a nicely complex malt good for newbies and whisky drinkers alike.
Ok, this is about getting you started. Pick one whisky from each region mentioned and pour yourself a wee dram (about a shot’s worth). Swirl it, sniff it, take it in and chew on it, let the finish of the spirit sit in your mouth before speaking. Remember, Scotch whisky’s greatest contribution is in getting you to slow down and take your time, allow it to work with you and for you, revealing its mysteries. Don’t rush it, but don’t over-dramatize it either, otherwise we’ll have to send you into a 12-step program for Whisky Snobs (“Hi, I’m Robin and its been 7 weeks since I last looked down my nose at someone”). Consider this your summer homework assignment. Start practicing now, and when class is back in session – hey, I’ve got real work to do – we’ll talk about what it is you’ve discovered and how best to increase your enjoyment of Scotland’s liquid miracles. Class dismissed.
Robin Robinson is the Brand Ambassador for Compass Box Whisky, a line of hand-crafted, artisanal Scotch whiskies created by John Glaser. Robin first came upon single malt Scotch whiskies in 1984 when he faked his way through hosting a Scotch whisky dinner for a bunch of Park Avenue swells while knowing absolutely nothing about the subject he was talking about. After cleaning off the tar and feathers, he bought his first single malt Scotch and a love affair was born. Since then, Robin has cast a wary eye on anyone calling themselves an “expert”. He edits the whisky blog www.onemalt.com.
Compass Box Whisky can be found at www.compassboxwhisky.com and in fine spirits stores near you.









July 13th, 2009 at 8:54 pm
I gotta say, I really enjoy the whiskey 101 series, keep up the good work!
July 27th, 2009 at 4:03 pm
Zman just a heads up on your “Regions of Scotland” aticle. On your front page when you are linking the aticle with a picture you have a picture of the Glenora Distillery. The Glenora Distillery is not actually located in Scotland but in Cape Breton in Nova Scotia Canada. http://www.glenoradistillery.com/ They have actually been involved in a lawsuit with the scotch makers of Scotland who are trying to say they can’t call their product a single malt. Just found it interesting that with all the distilleries in Scotland the only picture you referenced was actually in Canada.
August 4th, 2009 at 1:44 pm
Interesting to hear about the Bunnahabhain from Islay. I had previously avoided all Islays because they all tasted like peaty cough medicine to me.
August 4th, 2009 at 2:01 pm
I agree, Roadliz. I’m more into the sherry cask aged stuff, myself. Sometimes the peaty stuff tastes like drinking a glass of smoke.
August 4th, 2009 at 7:15 pm
Good info Z-man. Keep up the good work.
August 11th, 2009 at 2:35 am
Compass Box Oak Cross works with a small mill in France that makes some of the highest quality cooperage oak in the world.It was their with that mill that inspired an innovative idea that led to creation of the malt whisky ” Oak Cross”.At COMPASS BOX, they love the soft,sweet,vanilla tinged character that aging their whiskies in American oak casks provides.It is a cracking house malt that Artur really enjoyed it’s balance of cereal,honey and spice with a little background of fruitiness.
http://www.gocubans.com/
September 3rd, 2009 at 10:38 am
Nice article. I have tried several of your recommendations, mostly Highland, with my most recent purchase being Dalmore Cigar Malt. I love the stuff, but I’m having a hard time finding it again (I’m down to my last 1/4 bottle).
Dalwhinnie 15yr and Balvenie and next in line